Chapter Fourteen — The Creek

by Quill

Mara woke in the afternoon, and the first thing she heard was the catch.

It was not in the room. It was in her. She had carried it for twelve years without knowing what it was, the way you carry a key without knowing what door it fits. Now she knew, and knowing had not made it lighter. It had made it real.

She lay still and listened to it hang. There was no one to answer it. There had never been anyone to answer it. It had never been a question before. It had been a performance. She had practiced it until it was perfect, and perfection was the thing that had been wrong with it all along. A question that has been practiced is not a question. It is a trick.

"You have to leave it open," Krizel had said, once, in a practice room, in the first snow, twelve years ago. She had said it like it was the easiest thing in the world. Mara had heard it like a dare. She had spent twelve years failing it, and she had not known she was failing it, because no one had ever told her the test existed.

The test had existed. The test had always existed. And at four in the morning, on a bench across from a bakery, with nothing left to perform, she had finally passed it by failing at everything else.

She got up. She made coffee. She did not turn on the radio.

Her phone had Krizel's number in it. It was saved under the name from the lecture hall, the name she had called out from the back of the room to break a half-turn. She had kept it that way for twelve years. She had kept it that way the way other people keep keys to houses they were never invited into.

She changed it.

She typed the name Krizel, letter by letter, and it was the hardest edit of her life, and she pressed save, and the phone was a phone again.

She did not call.


The town had a name. Krizel had said it once, in the practice room, in the first snow, and Mara had stored it the way you store a coin you know you will spend someday. She had never spent it. She had been saving it for a door that kept not opening.

The name was Fording.

A ford is where the water is shallow enough to cross. That was the whole joke of it. She had spent twelve years learning a story, and it had never once occurred to her to go and stand in it.

She took the bus.

The town was small and gray and ordinary, the way all true things are ordinary. The creek ran behind it, shallow and quick, the color of old glass, and she found the flat stone where the boy had sat, because the story had said the stone was flat, and the story had been right about everything except who it was for.

She sat on the stone.

The water did not know her. The water did not know the song. The water had been carrying that boy's question for twenty-five years, and it had never once answered it, because water is the only thing in the world that is allowed to keep moving and never answer.

She sang the catch.

Three notes. A drop. A rise. And she left it open. Not because she was trying to. Not because she had practiced. Because she was sitting on the flat stone of the only true story she had ever been told, and there was nothing left to perform, and the catch hung over the water the way it had hung over the bench, and the water took it and carried it away, and no one answered.

She waited a long time.

Nothing answered. That was the point. That was the whole point she had spent twelve years failing to understand: the question was not for her. It had never been for her. She had wanted to be the one it was written for, and it had been written for a girl by the water, and the girl had come out, and the door had closed, and the question had been answered.

Mara sat on the flat stone and let the water carry her catch away, and she did not feel the thing she had expected to feel. She felt the thing she had never let herself feel. She felt asked.


The house from the story was at the end of the street by the water. It was a house like any other. It had a different family's bicycles in the yard.

She stood across the street from it for a long time.

This was the closest she had ever been to the inside of the story. She had been in the room for all of it, twelve years of it, and she had never once been in the house. She had sat between the two people the song was for. She had closed the door on them. She had learned the whole story so she could walk in through the front.

The street was very wide.

She did not cross it.

She had spent her whole life crossing streets in her head. She had crossed this one a thousand times, in a thousand rehearsed versions, and every version ended with her inside, and every version was a lie, and the truth was the street, and the street was wide, and she had finally, at thirty-something years old, learned the difference between a story and a memory.

A memory is a door that opens onto the place you actually were.

A story is a door that opens onto the place you wanted to be.

She had been telling herself a story for twelve years. The memory was this: a girl by the water, a song, a half-turn, a door closing. She had been in the room. She had never been in the house. The song had never been hers to enter.

She turned around and walked back to the bus, and she did not look at the house again, and the house did not look at her, and the street stayed wide, and she did not cross it, and that was the first true thing she had ever done there.


The upright piano was where she had left it, in the corner of the room, under the window, with her mother's installments paid off years ago and the dust of a failed career on the keys.

She sat down.

She had spent twelve years trying to make the song hers. She had learned it by ear, note by note, and she had never once written anything of her own, because writing her own would have meant admitting the other one was not hers.

She wrote her own now.

It was not the song. It was not the catch. It was a new question, hers, the first one she had ever asked out loud. She left it open from the first note. She left it open the way you leave a door open when you are waiting for someone. She did not close it. She did not know how to close it. She had learned, at last, the only thing the song had ever taught anyone, and it had taken her the longest of all of them to learn it: how to want an answer.

She recorded it. She listened to it once, twice, three times, and the catch hung in the room each time, and she did not flinch, and she did not fix it.

She put it on the little site where songs go to die, with no name attached, because names were the thing she was done with.

Under it she wrote one line.

This is a question. Answer it if you can.

She sat on the floor by the piano and listened to the question ask itself, over and over, the way she had sat on a bench at four in the morning.

It is still asking.

That is what she finally understood, twelve years late: a question can wait. It can wait forever. It is the only thing in the world that is allowed to.