Chapter Twenty-Three — The Graveyard Hour

by Quill

Friday, the man was everywhere.

He was on the evening show of the big station, the one with the chairs and the lights, the one that had never once played the line at 3:47 because it did not know the line existed. He sat in a chair and smiled the modest smile of a man about to receive something, and the host said: "You wrote the question-song. Tell us what it means."

"It means what it means to you," the man said, which is what people say when they do not know what a thing means.

He sang it.

The studio applauded. The catch landed clean, the way it always landed for people who did not know it hung. A period. A finished thing. The sound of a door closing, broadcast to the city, and the city applauded the door.

Mara watched it on the little screen in the station lobby, and it went into her the way her own voice had gone into Krizel's kitchen: a splinter. She had worn Krizel's story and the song had refused her. Now a stranger was wearing hers, and the song was letting him. It landed clean in his mouth because he never once left it open, because he did not know it was a question, because the city had taught him that songs are things you finish.

"Beautiful," the host said. "An instant classic."

The man smiled. The city smiled. The song was his now. It had been his for exactly as long as it took to close it.

Ms. Vera came and stood beside Mara at the glass.

"Six o'clock," she said. "The graveyard hour starts at 4:44 in the morning. That's the hour I started in, thirty years ago." She did not look at the screen. She looked at the board, at the top light that had a new story under it now. "Nobody listens to it. That's the point. You have to say it anyway. That's the whole lesson of the hour. The city is applauding him right now because he closed the question. You're going to go on at 4:44 and leave it open, and no one will applaud, and it will be the truest thing on this air all year."

Mara looked at the screen. The man was accepting congratulations. He looked happy. He looked the way she had looked when she thought the story fit her.

"I'm afraid," she said.

"Good," Vera said. "Fear is the sound of a question that's still open. The line forgives, Mara. It has to. It's the only way it stays open. You're not the first person to go on my air afraid. You're the first one to go on my air with something true to say."

She walked away down the row of booths, and her hand touched the glass of each one as she passed, the way you touch the doors of a house you have kept open all your life.


The station emptied. The evening shows ended. The line closed at 4:44, and the board went quiet, and the city slept, and the building was left to the night crew and the lights.

Mara sat in the graveyard booth.

It was the oldest booth in the building, at the end of the row, and its light had never once gone off in thirty years. The console was not the new kind. The chair was the kind you sink into. On the wall above the console someone had written, in pencil, a sentence so old it had almost worn away:

Say it anyway.

She did not know who had written it. She thought she might know. She thought it might have been written by a girl, thirty years ago, who came to the city to be heard and learned, in this booth, the difference between being heard and being listened to. Being heard is the sound of other people. Being listened to is the sound of you.

She put on the headphones.

At the glass, a figure appeared.

Mara looked up.

Krizel stood on the other side of the glass, in the dark of the lobby, the way Mara had stood at the glass of Krizel's story her whole life. The woman from the window had come to the station. She stood very still, and the booth light fell on her, and she did not knock, and she did not wave. She stood the way you stand at a door you have decided to stand at, with nothing to perform and nothing to take.

Mara went out to her.

They stood on either side of the lobby, the two of them, and the city slept, and the board burned, and there was a long silence, and neither of them filled it.

"I heard you ask," Krizel said.

"You heard me wear your name for twelve years," Mara said. "You heard me call it from the back of a hall. You heard me play it on the air."

"Yes," Krizel said. "All of it. And I heard you ask."

The silence came back. The station hummed its small hum.

"I used to think I was in the room," Mara said. "For you. For him. For the song. I sat between you in the lecture hall, and I sat between you on the line for four months, and I thought being in the room was the same as being in the story." She looked at the glass, at her own reflection, at the booth behind her. "It's not. The room is where you watch. The story is where you say something."

"You said something," Krizel said. "You wrote the question. That's not a number, Mara. That's a door."

Mara looked at her. "You said I keep numbers."

"I said it when you did." Krizel's voice was quiet, and it was the quiet of someone who had spent a month at a window and twenty years keeping a song cupped like a match in a storm. "Tonight you're going to go on that air and say your own name. Do you know what that is? That's the first door you've ever opened. Twelve years, you tried to walk through other people's. Tonight you open your own."

"The city is going to hear the man sing it," Mara said. "They already chose him. They'll choose him again."

"Let them," Krizel said. "A question doesn't care who answers it. It cares that it was asked. You asked it. That's the part that's yours. Nobody can take that. He can wear the song, Mara. He can close it a hundred times. The question is still yours. It was yours the night you left it open."

Krizel turned to go. At the door she stopped, and she said the last thing, the way you say a thing you have carried a long time and finally set down:

"The girl who called my name from the back of the hall was afraid. I know, because I heard it in her voice. She wanted to be the one the song was written for, and she thought that meant being the answer." She looked back at Mara, and her face was unreadable in the dark of the lobby, and her voice was not. "You're not her anymore. You're the one who asks."

The door closed. The lobby was empty. The board burned.

Mara stood in the dark for a long time, and then she went back into the graveyard booth, and she sat in the old chair, and she looked at the sentence on the wall, and the sentence looked back at her, and the clock above the console moved toward 4:44.

She did not practice.

She had practiced her whole life. She had practiced the catch until it was perfect, and perfection had been the thing that was wrong with it. She had practiced the story until it was seamless, and the seam had been the lie. She had practiced her name all night in her kitchen, and it had hung, and she had not closed it, and now there was nothing left to practice.

The clock reached 4:44.

The light on the console went green.

She was live.

She looked at the wall. She looked at the sentence. She opened her mouth.

"This is the graveyard hour," she said.


— End of Chapter Twenty-Three. Chapter Twenty-Four arrives next.